if you only need to catch layout and style changes, start with Playwright’s built-in screenshot comparison, which costs nothing. If you want a review dashboard, the free tiers of Percy, Chromatic and Argos each include 5,000 screenshots a month (prices checked 16 November 2026). Applitools Starter is $667 a month, so it only makes sense when pixel diffs create too much noise for your team. Applitools says its Visual AI cuts that noise. We did not test that claim.
What we tested, and what we did not
We built a small fake shop (the AI Testing Guide Demo Shop, fake data only) and took 1280 by 720 Chromium screenshots of one product page in three states: the original, a redesign (different colours, font, spacing and a rounded button), and a tiny change (the button made 1 pixel wider). We compared them with the pixelmatch pixel-diff library. Playwright’s own screenshot assertion also failed when we ran it against the redesigned page.
| Comparison | Pixels that differ (threshold 0.1) | Share of 921,600 pixels | Threshold 0.5 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Original vs original | 0 | 0% | 0 |
| Original vs redesign | 79,587 | 8.6% | 25,605 |
| Original vs button 1 px wider | 250 | 0.03% | 105 |
Two things follow from this. A pixel diff is exact: two identical renders gave zero differences, and even a 1 pixel change was flagged. And the same exactness is the weakness. On a real site with dates, ads, animations or changing data, every small change fails the check unless you mask it. Our shop has fixed data, so we did not measure that noise.
Not tested: we did not run Applitools, Percy, Chromatic or Argos ourselves for this page. Prices and free-plan limits come from each vendor’s pricing page on 16 November 2026. We have written separate hands-on notes in our Applitools review and Percy review.
Applitools alternatives: prices and free tiers (checked 16 November 2026)
| Tool | Free tier | Paid plans | Notes from the vendor page |
|---|---|---|---|
| Playwright toHaveScreenshot | Free, open source | None | Runs in your own tests and CI; you store the baseline images yourself |
| Percy (BrowserStack) | 5,000 screenshots a month, unlimited users, 1 month of history | Desktop $199 a month (10,000 screenshots, billed annually); Desktop and Mobile $599 (25,000) | Extra screenshots cost $0.036 (Desktop) |
| Chromatic | 5,000 billed snapshots a month, Chrome only | Starter $179 a month (35,000); Pro $399 (85,000) | Built by the Storybook maintainers; Safari, Firefox and Edge start on Starter |
| Argos | Hobby plan: 5,000 screenshots a month, single user | Pro from $100 a month (35,000 screenshots) | Team review features start on Pro |
| Applitools (for comparison) | No free plan listed; free trial | Starter $667 a month billed annually (100,000 component or 1,000 page checkpoints); Professional and Enterprise by quote | Visual AI is the main selling point |
Snapshots are counted differently by each vendor, so 5,000 does not mean the same amount of testing everywhere. Chromatic, for example, counts billed snapshots and says its TurboSnap feature reduces the number you use.
Which one fits you
One developer, a small site: use Playwright’s built-in comparison. You get the same pixel check we ran, with no account. The cost is that you review failures in the test report and manage baseline images yourself.
A team that wants a review screen: try the free tiers of Percy, Chromatic or Argos first. Chromatic fits teams that already use Storybook; Percy fits teams that already use BrowserStack. Check that the free limit covers your pages times your browsers times your builds, because that is where the 5,000 runs out.
Many pages, lots of dynamic content, a budget: this is where Applitools claims an advantage over pixel matching. Ask for a trial and run your own noisiest pages through it before paying $667 a month.
Before you switch
Run the same ten pages through two tools for a week and count false alarms. That number, not the feature list, tells you which tool costs your team less time. For the wider picture see our visual regression testing guide, Applitools vs Percy and best AI visual testing tools.
Sources: vendor pricing pages for Applitools, Chromatic, Percy and Argos, read on 16 November 2026. Test files: AITG Demo Shop v2, Chromium, pixelmatch.
One useful email a week
New guides, tool price changes and AI testing news. No spam.





